• 2023
    Kevin McElynn
    Baldwin
  • 2020-22
    Leon Tucholski
    Freeport
  • 2018-19
    Michael Krummenacker
    Hicksville
  • 2017
    Lawrence Dixon
    Wantagh
  • 2016
    Stephen Goodman
    Great Neck Vigilant
  • 2015
    Walter Frame
    Albertson
  • 2014
    Otto Kohlmier
    Hewlett
  • 2013
    Richard Messina
    Bellmore
  • 2012
    James Interdonati
    Port Washington
  • 2011
    Robert Ottaviano
    Glenwood
  • 2010
    G Michael Godfrey
    South Floral Park
  • 2009
    Thomas Gaffney
    Syosset
  • 2008
    Kevin McElynn
    Baldwin
  • 2007
    Robert Broccolo
    Bayville
  • 2006
    Michael DeStefano
    Mineola
  • 2005
    Leon Tucholski
    Freeport
  • 2004
    Jason Meier
    Great Neck Alerts
  • 2003
    Michael Reid
    Merrick
  • 2002
    Steven Klein
    Oceanside
  • 2001
    Donald Ellison
    Glen Cove
  • 2000
    Robert Hare
    Massapequa
  • 1999
    John Lasek
    Albertson
  • 1998
    James Bove
    Malverne
  • 1997
    Edward Sendlenski
    Roslyn Rescue
  • 1996
    William G Pokorny
    Mineola
  • 1995
    Walter J Monster
    Freeport
  • 1994
    Thomas Murray
    Port Washington
  • 1993
    Charles Razenson
    Bethpage
  • 1992
    Raymond Hornosky
    Oyster Bay
  • 1991
    Roy K Dahlen
    Merrick
  • 1990
    Benedict Russo
    Massapequa
  • 1989
    Gregory S Turrell
    Malverne
  • 1988
    Philip Grella
    Sea Cliff
  • 1987
    Anthony J Rypka
    Great Neck Alert
  • 1986
    Thomas J Cuff
    Levittown
  • 1985
    James Brandt
    Oyster Bay FC # 1
  • 1984
    Richard Lenz
    North Merrick
  • 1983
    Peter Tennis
    Albertson
  • 1982
    Charles Lustik
    North Bellmore
  • 1981
    Cosmo Stigaro
    Bayville
  • 1980
    Henry Greestein
    East Rockaway
  • 1979
    Thomas Baker
    Williston Park
  • 1978
    Joseph Trecassi
    Rockville Centre
  • 1977
    Edward V Horan
    Locust Valley
  • 1976
    Arthur W Lewis
    Freeport
  • 1975
    Anthony Paradise
    Manhasset
  • 1974
    George H Arend
    Malverne
  • 1973
    William Bernstein
    Roslyn Rescue
  • 1972
    Fred J Mayer
    North Bellmore
  • 1971
    John S Oliveri
    Albertson
  • 1970
    Frank S Nicoli
    Westbury
  • 1969
    Peter A Irace
    Mineola
  • 1968
    Walter Brower
    Woodmere
  • 1967
    Joseph Mastro
    Manhasset
  • 1966
    Carl Jackson
    East Norwich
  • 1965
    Arthur Bizzoso
    North Bellmore
  • 1964
    Reginald D Bedell
    Port Washington
  • 1963
    Donald E Kiefer
    North Merrick
  • 1961
    James Sansoverino
    Bayville
  • 1960
    Frank J Smith
    Freeport
  • 1959
    Conrad E Diem
    Albertson
  • 1958
    George Herrmann
    Valley Stream
  • 1957
    George Gengarelly
    Glen Cove
  • 1956
    S Walter Van Nostrand
    Rockville Centre
  • 1955
    Leroy Kinsey
    Mineola
  • 1954
    James McInnes Jr.
    Syosset
  • 1953
    Fred A Williams
    Great Neck
  • 1952
    Kenneth L Lewis
    Freeport
  • 1951
    William Bickell
    Manhasset
  • 1950
    George Metzler
    Woodmere
  • 1949
    Robert L Sheen
    Sea Cliff
  • 1948
    George Clay Sr.
    West Hempstead
  • 1947
    Harry Borley
    Hicksville
  • 1946
    Robley E Jarvis
    Albertson
  • 1945
    John Gorman
    Mineola
  • 1944
    Harold McGinn
    Inwood
  • 1943
    William McCarthy
    Port Washington
  • 1942
    Anthony L Giordan
    Elmont
  • 1941
    Mario A Pollini
    Malverne
  • 1940
    Edwin C Smith
    Manhasset
  • 1939
    Henry A Gebhart
    Hicksville
  • 1938
    Roy Westland
    Cedarhurst
  • 1937
    Roswell D Miller
    Roslyn Heights
  • 1936
    William Kirk
    Inwood
  • 1935
    William F Hewitt
    Port Washington
  • 1934
    Frederick F Wiedner
    Valley Stream
  • 1933
    Howard E Pearsall
    Freeport
  • 1932
    Charles S Miller
    Glen Cove
  • 1931
    Herbert B Ninesling
    Great Neck
  • 1930
    Leon Marsh
    Baldwin
  • 1929
    Hamilton G King
    Freeport
  • 1928
    James W Dickenson
    Port Washington
  • 1927
    George Miller
    Glen Cove
  • 1926
    James Keeley
    Oyster Bay
  • 1925
    William Strobson
    Lynbrook
  • 1924
    William Hickson
    Roslyn
  • 1923
    John Rosenburg
    Locust Valley
  • 1922
    Henry N Buck
    Westbury
  • 1921
    William Karm
    Lynbrook
  • 1919-20
    Arthur Campbell
    Glen Cove
  • 1916-18
    William Stopel
    Hempstead
  • 1915
    William Mullon
    Great Neck Station
  • 1914
    Edwin J Longham
    Lawrence
  • 1913
    George H Ellard
    Great Neck
  • 1912
    Harry F Werber
    Hempstead
  • 1911
    Fred P Bennett
    Hempstead
  • 1910
    George H Cornelius
    Roslyn
  • 1909
    George Hoffman
    Glen Cove
  • 1907-08
    J Hyler Ellison
    Freeport
  • 1906
    Henry Skinner
    Mineola
  • 1905
    Floyd Weeks
    Hempstead
  • 1904
    Cornelius Remsen
    Roslyn
  • 1903
    Howard H Mayland
    Freeport